Pixel C review: hands-on with Google’s productivity tablet

pixel-c-hero

Today we’re going hands on with Google’s Pixel C, the first Pixel device to be released with Android on board instead of Chrome OS. Like a Nexus device, this 10.2-inch tablet comes with the latest version of stock Android (Marshmallow), but it’s built by Google’s in-house team rather than an external manufacturer like Huawei or Motorola. It also sets itself apart from its peers with a unique keyboard cover accessory, which could make it a productivity powerhouse. Let’s see how it does!

Design

design

From the moment you grasp the Pixel C for the first time, you get a sense that this isn’t any run-of-the-mill Android tablet. Its anodised aluminium shell grants it a certain weight and dignity; it feels incredibly durable and well-made. That goes double when the keyboard cover is attached, which hides the screen from view and presents a tough metal façade from every angle. The metal construction makes this a very slick tablet (quite literally), so you might want to get a case to prevent the edges from getting chipped.

2015-12-14 13.33.35 copy

The Pixel C, with keyboard cover, compared to an early 2011 15-inch MacBook Pro

Pop it apart, and the screen inside will be revealed. Bring the two pieces together again in a certain way and pull, and you’ll reveal the strong magnetic hinge that comes out of the top section of the keyboard. From here, you can freely adjust the angle like a laptop, and gain the same comfortable arrangement for typing. It also shows off the pulsing, multi-coloured lightbar from Google’s earlier Pixel laptops, which sits on the back of the tablet and doesn’t really do anything except look frickin’ cool.

2015-12-14 13.31.45 copy

Keyboard and display

The keyboard of the Pixel C is definitely its most significant feature, so let’s take a closer look. It has a spartan appearance, with white lowercase on black chiclet keys, and it replaces Cap Lock with Search like a Chromebook. Some keys are unusually sized; the ‘1’ key is twice the size of ‘2’, while the apostrophe key is almost unusable as it’s half the width of a standard key. Still, Google have found room next to the space bar for a … key, which brings up the on-screen symbol keyboard.

The travel of the keyboard is reasonable, but even without taking into account the layout issues it still doesn’t compare well against a good laptop keyboard (e.g. that of a Macbook Pro). There’s no touchpad either, so you’ll be moving your fingers to the screen to make selections and operate apps.

2015-12-14 13.31.19 copy

The keyboard does have some strong positives too, though. It holds the screen very firmly without wobbling, unlike some other tablet keyboards. While it doesn’t connect automatically once the magnetic attachment is made, the Bluetooth connection feels stable and I didn’t experience any input lag. The keyboard also looks good, which is a nice bonus.

The other good-looking part of this tablet is the display. The 2560 x 1800 LCD screen reproduces text crisply and images with vibrant colours; there’s remarkably little backlight bleed too.

Productivity

The keyboard attachment should make the Pixel C a strong productivity machine, in the same space as Apple’s iPad Pro or Microsoft’s Surface tablets. Sadly, Google miss the mark here, largely thanks to limitations of the Android OS.

With no form of split-screen multitasking or windowing, you have to flip through apps—clumsily using alt+tab or taking your hands off the keyboard to use the app switcher. It’s possible to root the tablet with a USB-C to USB-A cable and enable Google’s rudimentary, pre-release split-screen mode, but this is far from a perfect solution. Once split-screen is officially released with Android N late next year, the Pixel C should be significantly improved… and it’ll be a lot cheaper, too.

2015-12-14 13.32.20 copy

Apps themselves are also a barrier to productivity on the Pixel C. Too often, tablet apps on Android are just blown up phone apps, with minimal (if any) layout changes to take advantage of that additional screen space. Even hugely popular apps like Twitter are affected, and it seems that Google still have yet to properly incentivise developers to build for a tablet audience.

It’s unfortunate that Google weren’t able to bring it to market as a Chrome OS device as planned, as this would solve a lot of the tablet’s issues and let it fulfill its natural role as a productivity machine. With proper multitasking (split-screen, windows) and a better range of work-focused apps, Chrome OS seems a much stronger choice. Still, that’s not what we’ve got with the Pixel C, so it doesn’t help the tablet in the here and now.

Performance

Wi-Fi performance is another annoying weakness of the Pixel C. Despite having a modern dual-band Wi-Fi ac solution on board, the Pixel C seems to struggle to maintain a connection to all but the strongest wireless signals. The Pixel C has a terrible time on our office Wi-Fi, with super-slow transfer speeds that make even loading simple websites or the Play Store an exercise in frustration. Compared to other smartphones, tablets and laptops in the office, the Pixel C has by far the worst connection. Other Pixel C owners have reported similar Wi-Fi performance issues (and even returned their tablets over it), so this seems to be more than an isolated incident.

2015-12-14 13.34.24 copy

The Pixel C, with keyboard cover, compared to an early 2011 15-inch MacBook Pro

Apart from the Wi-Fi, performance seems average to good. Storage speeds are a bit below par (about half the speed of the Nexus 6P, in some measurements), but the CPU and GPU both seem up to the task even in demanding 3D games and there’s little lag when navigating around the stock Android OS. This is rarely an issue for anything other than a low-end tablet, but it’s still good to see that box safely ticked on the Pixel C.

Conclusion

The Google Pixel C is a conflicted device. It is a gorgeous work of engineering, with well-chosen materials, beautiful details and a cleverly connected keyboard cover. Stock Android Marshmallow is a pleasure to use, with the mid-range hardware inside providing buttery smooth performance. If you want a small, premium tablet for reading, apps or games, this is a great choice.

But the Pixel C isn’t supposed to be just a stylish but standard Android tablet: its keyboard cover immediately suggests a niche as an ultra-portable productivity machine. Sadly there are some big issues that remove it from consideration: there aren’t enough tablet apps, split-screen multitasking is a no-go and the keyboard has a few weird foibles.

If you want to get work done on the Pixel C, then wait for version two, wait for Android N’s split-screen mode, wait for enterprising hackers to get Chrome OS running somehow. If you can’t wait, get a Surface or an iPad Pro; they’re much better productivity machines than the Pixel C.

Shop for Google Pixel C accessories >